Our Top 3 Picks
When it comes to dog training, there are different opinions not only from dog owners but also from breeders, vets, and trainers alike. Some believe a heavy hand can be helpful to correct unwanted behavior such as shock collars, but there are others who believe more human options such as citronella collars can help train out the bad behavior. There is one other option – vibrating dog collars. These collars can often have different training modes and vibration levels.
If you are a firm believer in human options to correct unwanted behavior as we are, then a vibrating dog collar is the best option for you. The best vibrating dog collars will have a variety of features which we will cover later. Let’s dive into our top 10 choices first.
We Think You’ll Like: Benefits Of Training With A Shock Collar
1. Best Value: PATPET Dog Training Collar with Remote Rechargeable Waterproof Shock Collar
The first option on our list is the PATPET Dog Training Collar. It’s one of the best vibrating dog collars simply because it features 3 training modes to help you find the most effective one for your dog and it comes with its own remote control. It works up to 1000 feet away so you won’t always need to be at your dog’s side.
Another great thing about the PatPet dog care training collar is it’s waterproof. The nylon belt is also a good material to have when the collar is in contact with water. The battery for these vibrating dog collars is rechargeable so make sure to pay attention to the battery indicator.
We love these training collars simply for the versatility. You can choose from beef, static shock or vibration modes.
2. Best Budget: DogRook Rechargeable Dog Bark Collar
These rechargeable vibrating dog collars are advertised as human. You can only choose from a variation of beeps and vibration levels with different levels of intensity. DogRook Rechargeable Dog Bark Collar works well against a dog’s barking and has proven to be 96% effective. These rechargeable versions can go 14 days on full battery life and only takes 2-3 hours to charge completely.
There is no remote control required as the collar can detect barks automatically and send out a warning tone beep then increase the intensity of the beef and vibration accordingly. It’s an easy to use option that can also be used for other unwanted behaviors.
The battery life is an essential part of the best vibrating dog collars. The fact that this option can last for 14 days and comes at an affordable price places it in the second spot.
3. Petrainer 998DRB Remote Dog Training Collar
For those who live in wetter climates, the Petrainer 998DRB Remote Dog Training Collar is one of the best vibrating training collars you can have. Aside from the vibration, the dog collar also features beep and shock training. If you feel like shock training is an inhumane option, you can forgo this feature altogether.
This smart collar is recommended and used by expert dog trainers and has been effective against barking, aggression, and instilling other behaviors in your dog. There are 0-100 levels for static stimulation and the remote control works from up to 100 yards away.
We always like a collar that is well-built and durable. The Petrainer dog collar is a rechargeable rainproof option for dogs that spend time outdoors.
4. Trulrox No Shock Bark Collar
Made for small dogs, the Trulrox No Shock Bark Collar only provides vibration mode for training. There are two modes to choose from, either a strong or a weak pulse to get your dog to stop what he’s doing. With an IP67 rating, the dog collar is water-resistant and can be worn into the water. The rechargeable battery has a long life span and you don’t need a remote to work the vibrating dog collar.
The collar automatically activates when it detects your dog’s bark. The sensors will not trigger due to another dog’s bark. Your purchase will also come with a free adjustable belt that is reflective for nighttime walks.
We like the bonus gift that comes with this purchase and the fact that the material is reflective only increases the safety of your fur baby.
We Think You’ll Like: The Pros and Cons of Bark Collars For Dogs
5. Bousnic Shock Collar for Dogs
For dog parents waiting for a compact and inconspicuous design, the Bousnic Shock Collar for Dogs is the one for you. Don’t be deterred by the name, the Bousnic dog collar offers more than just shocks for behavior correction. However, the beef and vibration mode in these dog collars cannot be adjusted. The safe shock mode is the only one that has 1-16 levels of intensity.
The white design gives the dog collars a sleeker and more futuristic look. The remote control matches the color of this vibrating dog collar and can work up to 1000 feet away. What’s great about this elegant vibrating dog collar is the IPX7 rating, which makes it safe for outdoor use.
Aside from the lovely design which we are big fans of, the dog collar has an IPX7 rating for dog owners and pets who love to participate in outdoor activities.
6. Flittor Dog Training Collar
Regardless of how effective and high-rated the Flittor Dog Training Collar, it ranks a little lower on our list due to the high price tag. This dog collar still comes with 3 training modes like its competitors and features a remote that works from up to 1000 feet away. How does it stand out? The IPX67-rated waterproof dog collar also has an LCD display with a backlit screen.
It’s also a multi-dog training system like many of the other ones on our list but it also boasts of memory settings for you to tailor your training with just one or multiple canines.
The Flittor dog collar is one of the best vibrating dog collars we have on our list because of it’s fancy bells and whistles. For a dog parent looking for a multi-functional dog collar, this is the one for you.
7. PetSpy P620 Dog Training Shock Collar
A suitable collar for new pet parents and pet trainers alike, The PetSpy P620 Dog Training Shock Collar can curb unwanted behavior within days if used correctly. There are 3 training modes with vibration training methods being one of them. You can adjust the intensity to suit your dog’s size and weight.
What’s awesome about PetSpy is they don’t only specialize in innovative and effective products like a vibrating collar, but they also offer dog parents the support they need with training videos, customer support, and a lifetime replacement guarantee that comes with their product.
Many people forget about the after-service when they purchase a product, PetSpy will be there to support you for a lifetime
Best Vibrating Dog Collars Buying Guide
Since the vibrating collar is something that will be in close contact with your dog’s skin, it makes sense that you will need to be even more careful about the materials used and the levels of vibration you set. A dog bark collar can come with multiple training modes as we have seen, but what else should we look for when training your pooch? Read on to find out!
The first and perhaps most basic feature you want in a dog vibrating collar is the training mode. We are mainly focused on vibrating collars, but it’s always a bonus to have other dog training methods available at your fingertips just in case the standard vibration mode doesn’t work.
Other training modes include the static shock, which is a hot topic of debate and there is the sonic training mode in which the module on the vibrating collars emit a sound of warning to get your dog’s attention. Unfortunately, collars vibrating may not be the best dog training method. All dogs are different and some do require a more severe way in the form of slight and safe shocks.
The more training modes a vibrating collar provides you, the more effective and quick the results will be.
We Think You’ll Like: 6 Best LED Dog Collars
Aside from multiple training modes, the vibrating collars also need to be adjustable in terms of severity. You don’t want to give your pooch a 100% shock when he only emits a guttural growl. Some collars only allow customizability for the shock mode while others allow for adjustment across the board.
The more levels the vibrating collar has the more versatility and intricate training you can do. We suggest looking for dog collar options that allow for 0-99 levels. This way, there will always be a higher level for your dog just in case he or she decides to act out. There will also be different severity levels for different barks. Maybe a growl warrants a 1-2 but a full-on bark is a 10 for example.
In terms of durability, the waterproof rating plays an important role. Ask yourself if you and your dog are the types to go into the water a lot during the summer or if you live in heavy rain climates. If so, getting a vibrating collar with a waterproof rating is your best bet. You can find ones that are IP67 or IPX7 among others. The IP chart is referred to as a waterproof rating chart, which will display the different levels of water-resistance a product has.
If your dog likes to swim, then you may need a vibrating collar that can allow for submersion for longer periods and not only a water-resistant model. Just a splashproof collar will also not be suited for water activities.
Remote Control or Automatic
There are some vibrating collars out there that are automatic and do not require a remote control for operation. This type of training collar can be referred to as a smart collar. It will trigger when it detects your dog’s bark. However, no matter how convenient it is, an automatic vibrating collar does come with issues. There may be room for error and you won’t be able to fully take control over the customization.
Ones with remote control will give you a 100% hands-on approach to training as you can tailor the different levels. You won’t be able to leave your dog to his business and will always need to keep a finger on the button for regular training. Whichever type you choose, make sure you are consistent each time.
If you prefer the remote-controlled vibrating collars, then you will know there is a certain range your dog must remain in for it to work. The wider the range, the more space your dog has to roam and the less you need to stay right by their side. Many of the vibrating collars we have on our list have at least 1000 feet of operating distance. So they are all good places to start for a long-range vibrating collar.
The battery life is also another important feature in terms of convenience. It’s not like a GPS collar, which will really rely on the battery life if your dog gets lost. It’s not fun to have to charge a product every time you want to use it, especially if it’s a daily necessity such as vibrating collars. The Slopehill Dog Training Collar is the one on our list with the longest battery lifespan of 15-20 days on a single full charge! The closest one after that lasts for two weeks.
Just because the dog collar has a long battery life doesn’t mean it takes longer to charge. Even with 15-20 days on the clock, the most a dog training collar should need to charge fully is 2-3 hours and less if possible.
The construction of these dog bark collar options are very sturdy and durable. However, another safety features you need when you train your dog is visibility. The belt of the dog collar should be made of durable material as well such as nylon and hopefully, it will feature some reflective trimming for nighttime visibility.
Lastly, one other feature a dog bark collar with vibration needs is the ability to hook up to and connect multiple dogs. This way you can train more than one dog at a time in the same way so their behavior is streamlined. This will also save you money because you won’t need to purchase more than one product. The most you will need to do is purchase another collar.
Related: Dog Collar Buyer’s Guide and Tips
Benefits of a Vibrating Dog Training Collar
Do you even really need a vibrating collar? What’s wrong with the age-old method of a regular collar and the word “no” coupled with positive reinforcement? We will start by saying that a vibrating collar will be far more effective in most cases. The shock value alone from a vibrating device on your dog’s neck is enough to at least get his attention.
Since it’s just with a slight vibration, this form of training is humane and painless. It will not cause your dog harm in any shape or form. Compared to shock collars, a vibration is much easier to accept than a shock collar, which could cause more aggression if not used correctly.
Sure, they can cost more and can be bulkier than other training collars thanks to the module, but the adjustable severity can prove to be more effective than just a spray collar.
One more benefit of a vibrating dog collar is solely for hearing impaired or elderly dogs. There are a lot of poor fur babies at the shelter that has physical ailments or deformities. If you manage to get a pup that’s hard of hearing, then traditional training methods cannot be implemented. This is when you enter the vibrating dog collar for simple training.
There are many other types of training collars, many of which we do not recommend such as the manual correction collars and choke collars. Shock collars are not the best either if they aren’t used in the right way. Sonic and citronella spray collars are the next best things in comparison to vibration collars.
They may only be a little annoying or catch your dog off-guard without ever having physical drawbacks.
We Think You’ll Like: A History of Dog Collars
Frequently Asked Questions
Do vibration collars work on dogs?
Yes, vibration collars work on dogs for the most part. There are some dogs that don’t find the vibration to be bothersome at all, which will prove to be less effective. The best way to ensure the success of vibrating training is to look for a collar that offers adjustable levels. This way, there will always be a level available to prove somewhat effective.
What is the best vibrating dog collar?
The best vibrating dog collar is the one from PATPET. This is a great example of a dog training collar that has different training modes for you to choose from including vibrations, sounds and shocks. Not to mention, the vibrating dog collars have a long battery life that takes no time at all to reach a full charge.
How do you train a dog with a vibrating collar?
You can train a dog with a vibrating collar by having intensity settings for different times of growls and barks. When your dog commits the crime, make sure you use the right setting on the dog collar to get his attention and to nip the behavior in the bud. The proven method to ensure a higher success rate is consistency. Make sure you always correct the unwanted behavior and do it in the same way.
Are vibrating collars bad for dogs?
No, vibrating collars are not bad for dogs but they are still classified by some as negative reinforcement training. Many dog parents and trainers stand by the positive reinforcement training above all and will not suggest using these types of collars. However, it depends on what you believe in and your dog’s personality. Some pooches just don’t listen without some sort of negative correction. If you have a pup like that on your hands then we would suggest considering vibrating collars first above ones that will instill pain.
Do shock collars make dogs more aggressive?
Unfortunately, it’s very possible for shock collars to make dogs more aggressive. What started off as anti-bark training may result in breeding aggression in previously friendly and happy-go-lucky dogs. We do not recommend shock collars or choke collars in fear of this adverse effect.
As a topic of many heated debates, if you must use alternative training methods aside from a keyword, we would suggest vibration, citronella, or sonic collars above all else. They are the more humane ways to train a wayward pup without crossing the line into cruelty. Many of the options on our list feature more than one training method, and again, we suggest bypassing the shock collar options and going for either the vibration or sonic options.
Did You Know?
The collar should fit like a regular collar and give enough space for two of your fingers to slide through at any point for a comfortable fit.
The belt of the dog vibration training collar should be adjustable to ensure a good fit even as your pup grows. The neck sizes of different breeds will vary, so we suggest measuring precisely with a measuring tape before purchasing.
- 3 Training Modes: Our training collar offers Static Shock (1-16 levels) and...
- 1000Ft Remote Range: You can be in the house to control the collar if your...
- Underwater Activities Available: IPX7 waterproof receiver can stay in the...
- 2 channels
- 3 training modes
- 330 yards range control
- Dog Training Collar Modes: NVK shock collar with 3 training modes (Static...
- 4 Channel: NVK dog shock collar with remote support a maximum of 4 dogs...
- 1600ft Remote & Waterproof: NVK shock collar for small/medium/large dogs...